Sword Coast Legends

There’s a game coming out in September (if the release date doesn’t get pushed back again!) called Sword Coast Legends (SCL). It’s an RPG in the same sort of style as Baldur’s Gate or Icewind Dale, and uses the Dungeons & Dragons 5e ruleset. I won’t bore you all by going over every detail. This post isn’t going to be a review of the entire game for a couple reasons: 1.) All my knowledge comes from watching the YouTube videos and Twitch streams by the developers that you could watch yourself, and 2.) there are plenty of people (bloggers, columnists, insiders, etc) who have had a chance to play through demos, and could offer a better review of gameplay than I could. In fact, here’s a link to the SCL news page, with all the aforementioned data, videos and opinions so far.

(TL;DR version: solo play, party-building RPG. Co-op play available with friends. Dungeon Master mode that allows you to use campaign/adventure/map/quest/NPC/monster creation tools).

What I do want to talk about is the amazingly versatile and powerful Dungeon Master tools, and what SCL could mean for old-school pen and paper gamers around the world, specifically because you can create adventures, or even whole campaigns, with those tools. I haven’t gotten a chance to get my hands on the game yet, but from what I’ve seen, you can create amazingly detailed quests and dungeons, as well as fun and varied NPCs and encounters. So, if you’re interested in a somewhat lengthy breakdown of the dungeon master tools, and my opinions on them (with pictures!), keep reading. Each section has a header, so feel free to skip past the areas that may not interest you.

Now, let’s take a look at some of the features in Dungeon Master mode.


Zone Creation

Many games allow you to create dungeons, and while SCL of course has that feature as well, it also gives you the ability to create outdoor and interior zones. The option to add NPCs inside houses, near market stalls on a city map, as well as create bandit camps outdoors, or spooky forest paths adds so much more depth to a campaign than we’ve seen in games like these before. I think that being able to add many different locations to a campaign will help players get more of a “pen and paper RPG” feel than other games have been able to provide.

Here’s an example of the zone creation UI:



Here’s an example of an outdoor area:



Here’s an example of an interior area:



Dungeon Creation

SCL’s dungeon creation feature is detailed, fun, and caters to (almost) any DM style. (More on this in a minute). Dungeons are able to be created on the fly with a versatile randomization tool that has many options to help tailor the randomness to your desires. Here are some of the ways you can customize before you even hit “create”:

  • Set the size of the dungeon. The number of floors to the dungeon (the max number is currently ten) and the number of tiles that are populated will vastly impact the time it takes to complete the area.
  • Decide the theme of the dungeon. (There hasn’t been much discussion on what this means, but I’m going to hazard a guess that it chooses lighting and fog defaults, possibly even ambient noise?)
  • Choose the complexity of the dungeon. This controls the number of branching pathways within the area.
  • Decide which tile set you want to use. This controls the shape of the rooms, and the look of the dungeon. For example, if the “sewer” tile set is chosen, you’ll get rooms that look like they have sewer water running under walkways, pipes, grimy stone walls, and all the features that you think of when you think of a typical sewer.
  • Choose two types of creature sets with which the tool will use to populate the dungeon. You can manually place creatures of different types within the rooms, but the tool will pull from the two specific sets you chose to generate random encounters. These creature sets can even be custom ones you’ve created ahead of time! While encounters are randomly generated, they can always be modified (sometimes from the ground up!) to suit your needs, or cleared completely. Encounters can be sets of monsters, single monsters, patrols, boss encounters, traps, ambushes… the possibilities are plentiful!
  • Mull over how evil you want to be to your players, and then decide the difficulty level for the dungeon.

You can also further customize each dungeon and area with unique names and flavor text that your players will see upon zoning in. This can help give your campaign and adventures a more personal feel, and give the players a bit of useful information (or even hints!).

Here’s a sample dungeon creation screen:



If a dungeon isn’t quite the right shape, a DM can always re-roll it to generate a different pattern of tiles until they find something they like.

At the beginning of this section, I mentioned how the SCL tools cater to almost any DM style. Unfortunately at this time dungeons cannot be created “tile by tile”. What this means is, you cannot place rooms down manually to form a dungeon of your own design. A lot of prospective dungeon masters are crying out against this, and I do agree that it would be nice to have complete control over the room placement. However, I only really design an adventure with a specific map in mind sometimes. Many times, I will use random dungeon generator tools I find scattered around the internet to come up with maps for my campaign. In fact, sometimes I come up with new ideas or twists because of randomized maps.

What I’ve seen so far from the tools allows a DM a multitude of ways to customize the randomized maps. Someone could take a generated map, and go room to room, painstakingly filling it out with traps, treasure, objects, NPCs and monsters, carefully cultivating the exact feel and story that they want to tell. The tools also allow a DM to roll up a quick map, populate it in minutes with fun challenges and bits of story, and dive right in to play with their friends.


Monster Customization and Control

Another really cool feature of the upcoming game is the ability to take the iconic monsters from Dungeons and Dragons and customize them with armor dyes, different weapons, and unique names. You can also scale the monster down levels, you can boost the monster up a few levels to give the players more of a challenge, or you can add all new abilities to throw your players off and make them think on their feet. Monsters can be “promoted” or “demoted” in real time to help DMs better control the challenge of their adventures. You can also knock health off quickly if your party is in trouble, remove them altogether, or spawn more on the fly.

Here’s a couple pictures of some of the customization possible:





But by far the most innovative feature has to be the ability that allows the DM to “jump into” a monster and take control of its abilities to wreak havoc on a party! I’m already envisioning epic RP monologues, taunts and jeers as the players and the DM battle it out in the middle of a dungeon, in real time.

As you can see below, the DM took over the big boss beholder at the end of the dungeon. A blue swirl appears below the monster to let the players know they’re not just up against an AI anymore! The bar at the bottom of the picture is a list of all the abilities the DM can use against the players:



Placeable Objects

Thankfully, DMs aren’t limited to using stock maps with static items. Dungeons can be filled with piles of bones, blood spatters, furniture (broken or whole), corpses, chests, crates, barrels, altars, torches… the list goes on and on! Even in interior areas, items can be removed and new ones can be added. Some objects are even breakable, giving DMs a whole new mechanic to tease, taunt, stymie, and challenge a player’s creative thinking!

Here’s a sneak peek at the UI for placeable objects:



Objects in SCL DM mode aren’t just available to spruce up player spaces, however. They can also be important to quest completion, and overarching campaign stories! The ability to add flavor text to objects gives DMs new ways to impart information, hints, and tips to watchful players. And the ability to attach quests to objects found in the world opens up the possibilities for adventure even more.

Here’s an example of the UI for adding quests to objects:



Traps and Obstacles

Even with all of these other features, what would a dungeon be, if it didn’t have traps? SCL delivers on this front, too, with a variety of different traps to pick from. Some randomly generated encounters will be rooms full of traps, but of course a DM can place them down manually to create hazards in front of doors, treasure chests, or wherever seems best (or worst, from the player’s perspective!). They can also be used to slow a party down, and make them look a little more closely at their surroundings.

Here’s what a DM sees when a trap is placed (the red outline is a placed trap, the green outline signals the area is a valid place to put another trap):



These aren’t the only challenges a party will face in a dungeon in SCL, though. The DM can also control access to treasure, story plot, and special rooms by locking an object, or making it “discoverable”. Full control over the difficulty lies with the dungeon master, as they can set the difficulty checks to be very high, to challenge the players, or very low, to make things a bit easier. Chests even have a “break open” check that can be set, so that anyone with the strength to do so can access the loot.

Here’s a shot of the UI to set the lock picking and break DCs:



If a “regular” object (not a door or chest) is made “discoverable”, extra flavor text can be added. This can help guide a party towards their goal, give them hints about possible dangerous to come, or be complete fluff! This can also be a useful way to hide a quest objective, to make the party really work for it!

Check out an example of this below:




If you’ve ever wanted to populate a 3D game environment with interesting characters and personalities, SCL can help. NPCs can be created quickly on the fly, or can be hand-crafted with gear, weapons, dyes, and special abilities.We haven’t been given the full details of character creation yet, but what we have seen is very promising.

Here’s a quick look at a couple sample NPCs created by the devs:





NPCs can be created as vendors to sell players items, they can offer tips and hints to the players via dialog, they can offer quests and reward players for completing them, and they can be assigned as allies or enemies. Setting an NPC to “hostile” means that it will attack the party on sight. Neutral NPCs remain, well, neutral. And if an NPC is set to “friendly”, they will follow the players throughout the zone and offer help against challenges, using whatever abilities they have to aid the party. If created as an ally, the NPC will have to be placed in each new zone the DM wishes them to appear in, as an NPC won’t follow a player across zone lines.

For example, if the party spoke to a mercenary in a city tavern, and hired them on as help, the DM would have to place the NPC at the start of the dungeon the PCs wish to tackle with the mercenary. I can see this being an amazing storytelling mechanic, as you can create helpful (or hindering!) allies that want to join the fun, or recurring villains that JUST. WON’T. DIE! (And maybe… later on… get switched from “hostile” to “neutral” or even “friendly” to force the party to work WITH them…?)



We’ve already touched a bit on this topic in almost all the previous topics, but let’s delve into this weighty subject properly now. The quest options in SCL are, simply put, astounding. Are they as detailed as a quest you could make in a pen and paper RPG? No, of course not. But they are damn good for a computer game.

There are a few different ways to craft the quests you’d like to use in SCL. Templates of popular types of quests are available for you to use. For example, there is a “kill quest” which is your typical “I need these monsters taken care of. I’ll reward you if you kill them” type of adventure. There is also a “defeat boss” template, which is exactly what it sounds like. and a “collection” quest template which would ask players to locate objects in the game. Using the templates is the quickest way to create adventures for your players.

However, by far the most powerful of the quest creation tools is the “custom quest” option. You can create a quest, assign it to a person or object with dialog and/or flavor text. You can create steps towards updating the quest, rather than just completing it with a single step. You can also create sub-quests and branching quests in this way. The versatility of the quest creation tools make a DM like me start thinking about all the different ways to use them to create stories immediately!

For example: Want to create a quest where the party is tipped off by a local merchant about a big baddie in the area waylaying caravans and would possibly have a reward for the players if they could defeat the monster? No problem. You create the dungeon for the players to enter, and populate it with monsters and cool objects. One of them is a corpse of a halfling adventurer just inside the door. When the party clicks on the dead person some flavor text pops up to reveal that the players found a diary. Inside, it hints at the location of a lost treasure to the east. Bam – new side quest! Now the players delve headfirst into the dangerous caverns. Along the way, killing a special goblin with custom gear and abilities updates the quest to find and defeat the boss! On death, some flavor text alerts the party that they found a key on the goblin. Apparently the main boss has a couple generals throughout the area that have to be defeated so they can collect the keys to unlock the boss’ ritual room! Eventually when the players finally reach the boss of the dungeon and kill it, the original quest is completed… but an altar at the back of the boss’ room hints at the growing influence of an evil cult. Perhaps that monster was just the beginning…

As you can see from just that quick example, you can layer quests to create a linking, overarching plot with many branching quests, sub-quests, hidden secrets, and lots of fun!

Here’s a sample of the custom quest UI and some ways you can add flavor text:




The last feature of the Dungeon Master mode in SCL I want to touch on is the way they’ve added ways to help the DM judge encounters and balance challenges. As the party goes through the dungeon and defeats monsters and traps, a special bar called a “threat meter” goes up for the DM. Points are added to the meter as the players successfully move through the encounters. These points can be spent by the DM to summon new monsters, place new traps, and directly control the dungeon denizens to give even more challenges to the players!

Conversely, if the party isn’t doing as well, the threat meter for the dungeon master decreases. This gives the DM a visual signal that maybe a few monsters need to be removed, or demoted to a lower level, or some traps need to be taken out. It’s a quick, easy way to signal the DM that the players are struggling, and need something just a bit easier.

Here’s what the threat meter looks like:



I absolutely LOVE this feature. As a DM, sometimes it’s hard to judge whether you’re challenging your players the right amount, A lot of times it’s easy to see when an encounter is too hard, and it’s very plain to see when it’s too easy, and the players breeze through your dungeon like a summer stroll! But the threat meter helps you gauge when you’re challenging them just enough, and gives you immediate feedback for when you should throw something extra their way, or ease off.

So now you know some of the neat features that will be included in the Dungeon Master mode available as part of Sword Coast Legends. And you may have been able to pick up on how excited I am by them… But WHY am I so excited you ask? Well, for a very good reason!

I am now in the category of those pen and paper roleplayers who are all grown up. We used to have dedicated groups with which to play Dungeons and Dragons, Pathfinder, Deadlands, or whatever RPG was hot at the time. Now? We find our gaming buddies scattered across not just the country, but the world. Gone are the nights when we would sit around the table for hours and delve into our imaginations with help from the DM. Gone are the days spent pouring over books and maps, creating adventures for our friends…

Or are they?

Sword Coast Legends actually offers a viable alternative to pen and paper gaming with friends far away. MMOs just didn’t cut it because they weren’t our own stories. Sandbox games are time consuming and often don’t have the features we’d like. But SCL delivers. Gather your friends and jump back into Faerun; create NPCs and monsters, quests and dungeons, even a whole campaign! But most of all; create new gaming memories with the people who helped you love adventuring.


Want to get in on the action? Pre-order now!


Want to read more game reviews? Try these:
EverQuest 2 Time-Locked Expansion Server
Project Gorgon

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *